51¶¯Âþ

Letters archive

Join the conversation in 51¶¯Âþ's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


31 January 2024

All of Earth's resources are precious and finite

From Georgina Seaman, Newbury, Berkshire, UK

I realise that it might just be a turn of phrase, but I am quite concerned about the use of "unlimited" with respect to tapping magma chambers as a source of energy. It may be an unimaginable amount, but it isn't unlimited. Ask anyone who has been in space and seen the finite size of …

31 January 2024

Anthropocene stand does not reduce climate concern

From Erle Ellis, University of Oxford, and Phil Gibbard, University of Cambridge, UK

We appreciate your efforts to present diverse views concerning the definition and application of the Anthropocene. Nevertheless, we are concerned by the closing quote of the article, which suggests that standing against defining an Anthropocene Series/Epoch in the geological time scale, as we do, is to deny anthropogenic global climate change. As scientists and as …

31 January 2024

Can't wait for great stargazing in New Zealand

From Dianne Khan, Porirua, New Zealand

When it comes to dark skies, Aotearoa (New Zealand) aims to be the world's first dark sky nation , a fact that warrants a mention. It is a lofty goal, but the country already has five dark sky reserves to enjoy while we wait for this to happen ( 6 January, p 28 ).

7 February 2024

Walk with a beep, walk with a squeak

From Phoebe Caldwell, Settle, North Yorkshire, UK

You report that beeping shoes boost walking ability in people with Parkinson's disease. Around 40 years ago, I was working with people on the autistic spectrum, one feature of which can be difficulty feeling the ground you walk on. When a colleague of my husband's got Parkinson's disease and was having difficulty walking, I suspected …

7 February 2024

How to explain and avert impending spermageddon (3)

From Dyane Silvester, Arnside, Cumbria, UK

Has anyone considered that the decline in sperm count and quality could be an attempt by Gaia to reduce the population of a harmful species? Perhaps Gaia is experimenting with gene drives in Homo sapiens in the same way that we have in mosquitoes, to make the vast majority of males infertile.

7 February 2024

There is no need for fish waste to end up as rubbish

From Joan Zealey, Balgownie, New South Wales, Australia

You report on the issue of organic waste generated by cod fishing. When I visited the Lofoten Islands in Norway, cod waste was turned into fertiliser. A little forklift trundled back and forth all day feeding cod heads, bones and skin from the fish finger factory into a fertiliser plant. It smelled horrible, but the …

7 February 2024

Just forget the idea of supersonic airliners

From Peter Leach, Nercwys, Flintshire, UK

Why is NASA wasting time and resources on commercial supersonic flight? Is it simply a demonstration of engineering ability? Such flight will only satisfy the egos of the super-rich, while helping to trash the environment for the rest of humanity. When Concorde was conceived in the mid-1900s, there was a need to speed up the …

7 February 2024

Not buying the quantum theory of consciousness (1)

From Gregg DuPont, Seattle, Washington, US

Stuart Hameroff and Roger Penrose's proposal that gravitational instabilities cause "collapse" of quantum wave functions in intracellular microtubules in the brain seems like a leap. To go from that to Penrose's suggestion that each time a quantum wave function collapses in this way in the brain, it gives rise to a moment of conscious experience …

7 February 2024

Not buying the quantum theory of consciousness (2)

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

The idea that the brain may exploit quantum effects in its operation left me with a profound sense of "so what?" Consciousness, however defined, is a phenomenon of the mind, which is embodied in the central nervous system. This is a biological entity, that relies on chemical and electrical processes, which themselves arise from quantum …

7 February 2024

What seems symbolic may just be utilitarian

From Gerben Wierda, Heerlen, The Netherlands

When archaeologists are confronted with observations for which they have no clear explanation, they often tend to attribute religious, or symbolic, significance, as with the straight roads between settlements found in the Ecuadorian Amazon. Might it not be that for some mundane, technical reason, such as a mode of transport, the roads needed to be …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with 51¶¯Âþ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop