Letters archive
Join the conversation in 51¶¯Âþ's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
12 June 2024
From Howard Bobry, Port Townsend, Washington, US
The idea that humans evolved endurance and stamina to chase prey might have it backwards. Prior to the development of sharp tools, we were ill-equipped to consume prey animals, lacking, as we were, the teeth and claws of a carnivore. Our early ancestors were gatherers, not hunters. It was us who were the prey, and …
12 June 2024
From Talia Morris, Cape Tribulation, Queensland, Australia
You discuss the idea that food addiction might be akin to drug addiction. This idea overlooks the fact that ultra-processed foods are designed to be over-consumed. They are visually appealing, intensely flavoured, energy dense goodies that beg sensory seeking while providing little satisfaction. These factors strongly encourage people to eat more of them than is …
12 June 2024
From Rachel Mckeown, Cambridge, UK
Although I see the potential for orchids to transfer food to seedlings via a fungal network, the study you describe reminds me of a limitation in experimental design – namely, that reducing complexity can give only a narrow window into a real-world ecosystem. I imagine a real mycorrhizal network doesn't link up with a single …
12 June 2024
From Cheryl Hillier, Lampeter, Ceredigion, UK
Again and again we read that some carbon emissions from agriculture are unavoidable. This view keeps resurfacing despite the best efforts of agroecologists, who will say that if we remove fossil fuel-intensive artificial fertilisers and farm in ways that support nature, instead of poisoning it, farming becomes carbon negative ( 25 May, p 12 ).
12 June 2024
From Stephen Johnson, Eugene, Oregon, US
You reported on a game theory simulation that showed people failed to reach a state of rational action, even after multiple failures and repeated feedback. This was said to be in variance with economic theories. However, the result is in line with over 50 years of research by psychologists on micro-economic decision making ( 18 …
12 June 2024
From John Byrne, Perth, Australia
I disagree that a steady decline in world population will hinder progress, provided we reach and maintain a sustainable level. Population in the year 1905 for Albert Einstein's work was a fifth of today. In the 1960s, when we went to the moon, it was less than half its current level. It is quality and …
12 June 2024
From Ben Crossley, Wigston, Leicestershire, UK
A 200-square-inch cake tin of the dimensions given by Keith Walters (14.14 inches per side) only allows 98 slices exactly 1 inch by 2 inches. Unless you somehow combine the bits left round the edges ( Letters, 25 May ).
19 June 2024
From Christopher Jessop, Marloes, Pembrokeshire, UK
James Wong needn't choose between drinking milk or using it as a plant fertiliser. Drink the milk, then, a few hours later, you can be fertilising plants with it – possibly in a way that makes it easier for the minerals etc. to be assimilated, especially if your efflux is diluted with soft water ( …
19 June 2024
From Trevor Jones, Sheringham, Norfolk, UK
Graham Lawton delved into the many benefits of using wood in construction beyond its ability to store carbon, and I can vouch for some. Years ago, I designed an award-winning school using Japanese-style hybrid-timber construction, including a laminated timber frame with solid-timber decking ( 8 June, p 24 ). The real reason for the choice …
19 June 2024
From Robin Stonor, Oxford, UK
Your review of the book Eruption got me wondering if it is possible to dump anything into an erupting volcano? Could, say, landfill waste be disposed of in the gaping "incinerator"( 8 June, p 30 )?