51¶¯Âþ

Letters archive

Join the conversation in 51¶¯Âþ's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


13 May 2026

Let's hope Q-Day becomes known as Quiet Day

From Mel Earp, Macclesfield, Cheshire, UK

I was both pleased and horrified by the article on Q-Day ( 25 April, p 10 ). Pleased, because the coverage and comparison with Y2K was accurate and measured, unlike some who declared it a hoax when, after the event, not that much went publicly wrong. I know it wasn't fake because, like many software …

20 May 2026

Getting your head around an infinite universe (1)

From Bryn Glover, Ripon, North Yorkshire, UK

Leah Crane quotes Catherine Heymans, the Astronomer Royal for Scotland, as being "very happy" to hear that the idea of a cyclical universe is currently receiving some increasing acceptance. I share the feeling, because I simply cannot get my head around the ideas of infinity and infinitesimal, in the form demanded by other theories ( …

20 May 2026

Getting your head around an infinite universe (2)

From Chris Ruff, London, UK

Roger Penrose's conjecture is that the universe will perhaps end in a state of extreme emptiness. Another proposition is that the end will occur because of the weakening of dark energy resulting in a big crunch. The possibility that our universe will go on forever is dismissed, thankfully; I cannot imagine holding a very long …

20 May 2026

Backing up the grid with electric vehicles (1)

From Martin H. van Raay, Hoorn, Netherlands

Using electric cars as a back-up for the grid is a great idea, but I doubt that EV owners could sell electricity at a premium, as Alec Luhn presumes. At the moment, in the Netherlands, you pay to put your surplus (solar) energy into the grid when the sun shines brightly. I don't see electric …

20 May 2026

Backing up the grid with electric vehicles (2)

From Brad Elliott, Sydney, Australia

In countries like Australia, EV batteries can be charged from solar panels and also supply power to the owner's home during peak evening times. This also requires the purchasers to choose an EV that is originally adapted to that role or pay for a conversion. It would be more economical for all if it came …

20 May 2026

Does AI really understand what it's saying?

From Jacqueline Christmas, Crediton, Devon, UK

I'm afraid that Colin Nicholson is mistaken in thinking AI understands the consequences of nuclear war. Large language models (LLMs) don't understand anything. They just produce sequences of words that are statistically plausible. What he has probably come up against is a human-imposed guard rail that tries to stop the LLM from giving out dangerous …

20 May 2026

Pondering the answer to unanswerable questions

From Ken Lignar, Westbrook, Connecticut, US

I enjoyed reading Jacklin Kwan's piece about John Pendry and his invisibility cloak. As the discussion talked about the way that the structure of metamaterials can interact with electromagnetic radiation (light), some questions entered my mind. Does empty space, with all of the virtual particles within it, have a structure? Is empty space a temporal …

20 May 2026

Separating reality from consciousness

From Robin Wright, London, UK

Have I got this right: some physicists and philosophers seem to think that reality cannot be separated from consciousness – human consciousness at that? I hope we can all agree that consciousness (not just human) is a biological phenomenon and one that arose later rather than earlier during the evolution of life. As for philosophising …

20 May 2026

Scorpion stingers and ancient Greek myths

From Alex McDowell, London, UK

Maybe metal in scorpions' claws and stingers inspired ancient Greek myths about creatures with metallic claws and beaks. It is possible that chemists (who were thought of as magicians at the time) came up with chemical tests for metals and found traces in scorpions' claws and stingers. In Greek mythology, the Stymphalian birds had bronze …

20 May 2026

Learning to think differently about AI

From Julia Stavenhagen, Hammond, Oregon, US

I was completely prepared to hate Jacob Aron's column about AI, since I have been dismally disappointed by the motivations of the companies that have trained models like ChatGPT with distressing biases towards "popular" answers that may decrease their accuracy. Aron clearly explained why AI models do this, and how he was able to focus …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with 51¶¯Âþ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop