51¶ŻÂț

Feedback: When roads burst into song

Terrible driving music, the National Union of Stew Departments, pyramid telling, and more

When roads burst into song

A CONVERSATION about “hearing maps” between 51¶ŻÂț editor-in-chief Jeremy Webb and Trevor Cox, professor of acoustic engineering at the University of Salford in the UK, led somehow or other to the topic of “singing roads”.

Hearing maps are software packages that architects use to identify potential areas of poor acoustics and unwanted noise in the buildings they are designing. “Singing roads”, on the other hand, are roads that make music – very badly.

If you don’t believe us on this point, go to , where you can enjoy a video of a car travelling over a customised road surface in Lancaster, California. Variations in the surface cause “musical” vibrations as the car runs over them.

The video helpfully points out that the caterwauling you can hear is, in fact, the road’s rendering of Rossini’s overture to William Tell. Other clips allow listeners to savour singing roads in Korea, Japan and Denmark. They all sound dreadful.

“Lost” study on cell phones unearthed

FEEDBACK thanks Alan Lewin of for sending us a link to research on shielding of mobile phones published by the UK government at . says that “A study published in May 2002 by the Department of Trade and Industry showed that devices to cut radiation from mobile phones can ‘significantly reduce’ exposure to potentially harmful radiation,” but neither we nor the DTI’s successor, the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS), had been able to find it (5 March).

The study, it turns out, was commissioned from Sartest Limited, now listed as “non-trading”. It did find significant reductions in exposure to radiation – but only by devices that clip over antennas, and by shielded cases. On what it calls “absorbing buttons” – of which the Phoneshield is an example – it reports that “none of the devices are very effective” in reducing specific absorbed radiation. It also notes that makers of button devices “are not usually specific about the basis of the claims”, with which we can only concur.

But how is a claim of reduced radiation relevant, when still says (as we go to press) that Phoneshield “does not attempt to stop or limit the level of radiation”? Lewin tells us that this qualification “is intended to highlight that
 claims of ’99 per cent reduction in radiation’ made by others make no sense because without radiation the technology wouldn’t function,” which is what we were thinking too. In fact, effectively shielding a phone can increase radiation emissions, as it tries harder to contact a base station.

Lewin also says that shielding “in itself would be ineffective”. That may well be true – but it still leaves us uncertain just how Phoneshield is supposed to be effective.

When we asked BIS about official responses to the report the DTI had commissioned, it suggested we file a Freedom-of-Information request. Watch this space.

National Union of Stew Departments

IN AN email headed “The comedy of subtitles”, Antony Badsley-Ellis tells us that he and his office colleagues entertain themselves by taking time off to read the subtitles on TV bulletins from the likes of Sky News and the BBC News Channel. These are generated in real time, he says, with some odd results.

Some names that the subtitles have got badly wrong include Sir Liam Donaldson, who became Silly and Admundsen, Sir Gus O’Donnell, who became Circus O’Donnell, and the National Union of Students which became the National Union of Stew Departments.

Then, back in November last year, there were repeated references to people wearing puppies (as opposed to poppies) for the UK’s Remembrance Sunday; the Office for National Statistics became the Office of Nursed All Statistics; “Principally chemical and biological weapons” was corrupted to “Prince of Chemical and Bionicle Weapons”; “government trying to make helpful decisions” became “government trying to make holes for surgeons”; and, at prime minister’s question time in the House of Commons, Ed Miliband, the leader of Her Majesty’s opposition party, was repeatedly referred to as Ed Miller Band.

What’s that in elephants?

READER Olaf Lipinski reports on what could be the start of a new trend in units of measurement. He tells us that the German news website Spiegel Online described the piece that broke off the Tasman glacier in New Zealand during the earthquake earlier this year as having “the mass of five Cheops Pyramids”.

This is all very well, but we can’t help asking the obvious question: “What’s that in elephants?”

Acts of God not covered

FINALLY, when Joshua Prettyman booked a holiday recently he was told that the refunds policy did not cover “acts of God”.

“What a relief,” says Joshua. “I was afraid that it might not cover unexpected meteorological, geological or hydrological occurrences.”