51¶ŻÂț

Feedback

Misleading and absurd

JUST occasionally, a promotion for a commercial product is so misleading it makes us huff and puff. An example is the publicity for a new skincare product called Neaclear. It is apparently “creating a big commotion in the dermatologic community”.

The company’s website () helpfully explains how “the body can only survive minutes without oxygen”. “Today’s breathable air,” it goes on threateningly, “contains less than 20 per cent oxygen” whereas “at one time, this number was more than 50 per cent”.

Shock, horror! The atmosphere is losing its oxygen! We’ve come across this rubbish before, and as far as the planet’s recent history is concerned, it is simply not true. The oxygen in our atmosphere has been stable at about 18 per cent for at least 3 million years – and the last time it contained anything approaching 50 per cent was some 300 million years ago, when people weren’t around to breathe it.

From the misleading to the absurd. Neaclear, we are told, contains a “powerful combination of liquid oxygen, vitamins C & E, sage, chamomile, seaweed and rosemary, coconut oil, sweet almond oil and hydroquinone”. At first we thought this might be a typographical error, but no, the company goes on to explain that Neaclear skin care “is the first to combine stabilised liquid oxygen into all of its products”.

This is “definitely unique”, says Neaclear, and we agree. We have certainly never heard of a skin cream that contains liquid oxygen, the temperature of which is normally somewhere below -183 °C.

Triumphant triontologias

TWO weeks ago we noted that you would be doubly truthful if you said of a computer-assisted tomography scan of a cat: “This is a cat scan” (20 August). We dubbed such statements diontologias and wondered whether there were any triontologias.

The challenge proved irresistible but hard to meet. The groan factor was high as readers struggled to find ways to satisfy the criteria using words such as “catastrophe”, “catalogue” and “tomography”. None really succeeded, and it was left to Nigel Steel to come up with what we felt was the best solution: “If you did a number of scans using positron emission tomography and an image of your own domestic animal companion was your personal favourite, then the statement, ‘this is my pet scan’, would be true to the third power.”

Quite right Nigel, and thanks. Thanks also to Tom Gallard who reached almost the same solution with his “pet pet project”. And we should mention the effort by Richard Saunders, who pointed out that if he bought a large musical instrument for £1000 and thought it was quite splendid, then the statement, “This is a grand piano”, would be true three ways.

Nail-biting Shuttle mission

NASA’s public relations department is crowing about drawing record internet traffic during the recent mission of the space shuttle Discovery. About 435,000 people watched the launch on its streaming video, and some 400,000 watched the landing. “We’re so excited that the world wants to be a part of the ongoing mission of exploration and discovery,” said PR chief Dean Acosta at NASA headquarters.

But the main reason so many people watched was left unsaid: it was the nail-biting suspense of expecting the mission to go horribly wrong.

“A sign spotted on the A1 road near Harrogate in the UK tells drivers to “follow the existing signs to Wetherby”. Chris Morley wonders how many drivers disobey this instruction and follow the signs that don’t exist”

Entomological embarrassment

WE ARE sure that Jonathan Wallace is a brave man, but he admits that he has been struggling to summon up the nerve to ask his local library to obtain a copy of An Amateur’s Guide to Genitalia by P. W. Cribb.

This, despite the fact that it is a bona fide publication by the UK Amateur Entomologists’ Society. It deals with the identification of moths, whose genital anatomy is often the key diagnostic characteristic in determining species.

Looking for the Grasp Nozzle

PROPER capitalisation can be more important than you might think. Dave Zwolenski and a colleague were happily writing up a safety manual for their workplace, until they came across the injunction in a fire extinguisher’s instruction sheet: “Remove locking pin and Grasp Nozzle.” They spent 20 minutes looking for a Grasp Nozzle to remove, until sheepish realisation dawned.

Mega-unit

FINALLY, John Elliott responds to our “unusual units” theme by telling us that there is a valley in Australia’s Blue Mountains, west of Sydney, “named for a very large unit of indefinite length. It is called Megalong”.

Nice try, John, but we don’t think this is what the Aboriginal people meant when they named it that.